Comparison
WhatsApp or Medley for your event photos?
Choosing between WhatsApp and Medley to collect your guests’ photos? This comparison covers how each works and the terms recorded in the sources below.
Look at the quality of sent files, how photos sit within the conversation and how to download them.
Related reading : Wedding photo sharing
What to compare
- Quality rides on a setting nobody touches
WhatsApp documents two sending qualities, Standard and HD, and Standard is what applies until the sender goes and changes it in their settings. Which means the quality of your album depends on forty phones you will never get your hands on.
- The memories drown in the thread
Three hundred messages, photos wedged between “who is driving whom?” and a question about the dress code: finding anything two weeks later is hopeless. The voice note a friend sends at two in the morning meets the same fate, stuck between two lift-sharing questions. In a guest book, it would be filed on its own, signed with a first name.
- Getting it all back is a chore
Downloading dozens of photos one by one, working out what order they came in, weeding out the duplicates of the duplicates: the job everyone puts off, which is why the photos stay in other people's phones forever.
- You have to be in the group
Guests you met that night, colleagues, distant family: they are not in your group, and they will not join it for three photos. A QR code, on the other hand, is open to everyone in the room.
How they compare
Photo and video quality
- WhatsApp group
- Two sending qualities, Standard (compressed) and HD, to be switched by each sender in their own settings
- Medley
- Original quality, with no setting to ask anyone about
The original file
- WhatsApp group
- Only travels as a document attachment, one file at a time
- Medley
- By default, with nothing to do
Organisation
- WhatsApp group
- A chronological thread, photos mixed in with messages
- Medley
- A dedicated album, photos and videos in their own place
Getting everything back
- WhatsApp group
- Downloaded photo by photo
- Medley
- The whole album in a single download
Who can take part
- WhatsApp group
- Members of the group
- Medley
- Anyone who scans the QR code or holds the link
Guest book (written, voice, video)
- WhatsApp group
- None: a voice note goes into the thread, next to the parking arrangements
- Medley
- A space of its own for words, written, recorded or filmed, each one signed with a first name
Hosting
- WhatsApp group
- US company
- Medley
- Hosted in the European Union (France, OVH), GDPR, no advertising
| Feature | WhatsApp group | Medley |
|---|---|---|
| Photo and video quality | Two sending qualities, Standard (compressed) and HD, to be switched by each sender in their own settings | Original quality, with no setting to ask anyone about |
| The original file | Only travels as a document attachment, one file at a time | By default, with nothing to do |
| Organisation | A chronological thread, photos mixed in with messages | A dedicated album, photos and videos in their own place |
| Getting everything back | Downloaded photo by photo | The whole album in a single download |
| Who can take part | Members of the group | Anyone who scans the QR code or holds the link |
| Guest book (written, voice, video) | None: a voice note goes into the thread, next to the parking arrangements | A space of its own for words, written, recorded or filmed, each one signed with a first name |
| Hosting | US company | Hosted in the European Union (France, OVH), GDPR, no advertising |
When WhatsApp is still the right choice
For organising (agreeing on a time, sending the address, sorting out who drives), the group chat is irreplaceable, and nobody here will tell you to close it. Just drop the link to your Medley album into it: the conversation on one side, the memories at full quality on the other.
Frequently asked questions
Why does WhatsApp reduce photo quality?
Can you send photos without compression on WhatsApp?
How do I get the photos out of a WhatsApp group?
Is a group chat private enough for wedding photos?
Read on
Get your album ready.
Create it now, then share the link or QR code when you’re ready.